#10 The Scream Heard Round The World

We’re into the top 10 of our 25 Greatest Oakland A's Wins countdown, and this is where the real debate begins. I'm sure many fans who read this blog will be wondering why this game isn’t higher on the list. I’ll address that question a little later in the post. Writing an introduction for this game is quite difficult as I remember experiencing so many varying emotions swirling through my mind from the first pitch to the end. Simply, there’s just not many games that have you like that.

Win #10 brings us back to October 10, 2012, for game 4 of the 2012 ALDS. The A’s and Tigers were quite evenly matched against one and other, but came into the post season with different expectations. The A’s were just happy to be there in some ways, while the Tigers were anxiously hoping they could convert on the championship window that was obviously right in front of them. 

In game one of the series, the A’s received a 'Rickey Henderson' from Coco Crisp to lead off the game, but that would be the only spark of offense the A's would see as Justin Verlander would shutout the A’s from that point on. The Tigers would go onto win 3-1 in a frustrating game. 

The next day was an early morning game that the A’s appeared to have by the throat in a pivotal game. A drop by Coco Crisp on a blooper from Miguel Cabrera would be the play everyone remembered and later on, the Tigers would walk-off on a sacrifice fly to rescue the game and make the series 2-0 Tigers.

The series then returned to Oakland. Due to odd scheduling mistakes, the 2-3 format was used in this series and the A’s would get the last three games at home. Already down, they would have to win all three to advance and keep their season going. In game three, Brett Anderson pitched a brilliant game after coming off a minor injury and then Coco Crisp made an unbelievable catch to rob Prince Fielder of a home run. A home run from Seth Smith would put the exclamation point on the A’s 2-0 shutout victory which seemed to re-energize the belief in the A’s. Fans and pundits alike were very impressed with the crowd support from game 3 and it seemed as though the reputation of Oakland fans was changing in those moments.

It was now a 2-1 series lead for the Tigers and game 4 would feature an interesting matchup. It would be Max Scherzer for the Tigers, and this was a year before Scherzer would have his breakout season, but he was still a pitcher who presented a tough matchup for the A’s. Scherzer was not at 100% coming into the game, since he sprained his ankle during the Tigers AL Central clinch celebration. That gave A’s fans some quiet confidence. A's fans were also encouraged by the fact that Scherzer is a guy who throws a lot of pitches so the A’s would get a shot at the Tigers’ suspect bullpen at some point in the game.

For the A’s, AJ Griffin was taking the hill. Griffin had an unbelievable year for the A’s.  Griffen was called up in late June and was an impressive surprise that was critical to the A’s run down the stretch in 2012. The problem was that, the last time the A’s fans saw Griffin was on the last day of the season where Griffin was pulled early (more on that game later). They say styles make fights, and Griffin was a more cerebral pitcher with softer pitches that relied on deception while Scherzer threw from an unusual arm angle with a nasty slider and threw very hard.

Image credit: Miriam Aguilar

Going into the series,  a key for the A’s was really trying to keep the Tigers' middle of the order from causing too much havoc. That middle of the order included the AL MVP from that year, Miguel Cabrera who was 4 for 12 going into game 4. The A’s had done a good job making sure that Cabrera was coming up with no base runners, since the A’s knew that he’d get his hits, it would just be a matter of making sure those hits didn’t play a part in the outcome of the games. The other two guys in the Tigers' middle of the order, on the other hand really were struggling: Prince Fielder was 1 for 12 in the series, and Delmon Young was 2 for 9.

The first two innings went rather predictably for both starting pitchers. Both would give up a single hit, with Scherzer overpowering the A’s batters and picking up 4 strikeouts. Griffin would take advantage of the Coliseum by getting 4 fly ball outs.

The 3rd inning would see the first run of the game as the Tigers catcher, Alex Avila would double and Tigers manager, Jim Leyland would call for Omar Infante to bunt which would move Avila to third with one out. Next up was Austin Jackson, and being ultra aggressive he’d line an 0-1 pitch into left field.  Avila would score easily. The Tigers had taken a 1-0 lead which would make the blood pressure raise a bit.

The A’s would go down quietly in the 3rd as Scherzer looked dominant. Things would only get worse for the A’s in the top of the 4th. Prince Fielder who had been having a difficult series broke his mini slump in a big way, on an 0-2 pitch, Fielder crushed one for a no doubt, solo home run. It was now 2-0 Tigers, and it was clear that the A’s were going to have to find some more comeback magic to keep their season alive.

Luckily for the A’s, the top of the 4th only saw one run come across the plate for the Tigers, Griffin was able to get a double play with runners on first and second to stifle the Tigers rally. In the bottom of the 4th, Scherzer faced Stephen Drew, Yoenis Cespedes, and Brandon Moss who seemed to be the only A’s hitters remotely close to getting contact against Scherzer. And unfortunately, this inning would be Scherzer’s least taxing as it turned out to be a 5 pitch inning with Drew lining out, Cespedes flying out, and Moss popping out to end the inning.

Griffin appeared to have settled down in the 5th for the A’s as he faced a 1-2-3 inning, suggesting that the double play in the previous inning had brought him new life. The A’s wouldn’t score in the 5th but they made Scherzer throw a taxing inning, even with the A’s striking out 3 times, Scherzer threw at least 5 pitches in each of those at bats. In total, the A’s forced Scherzer to throw 29 pitches in that inning which more than made up for the 5 pitch inning he threw in the inning previous.

The top of the 6th would see the end of AJ Griffin’s day. Griffin would give up a leadoff single to Miguel Cabrera. He had only thrown 85 pitches, but Melvin could not afford to take any chances especially with Fielder and Young coming up. Melvin would go for the lefty specialist, Jerry Blevins who had been dynamite all year for the A’s. Blevins would do the job once again, forcing Fielder to ground to Stephen Drew, who stepped on second and fired to first for a rally stifling double play. Blevins would then get Delmon Young to groundout to end the inning with no damage done.

The bottom of the 6th would also see the end of Scherzer’s day as well. Coco Crisp would reach on a Prince Fielder error that would allow Coco to end up at second. Scherzer would then let a slider get away from him and Crisp would advance to third. Then the A’s thought they had just hit the jackpot, as Stephen Drew would hit a Scherzer 3-2 pitch into the gap in right-center, and Coco would walk home. While Drew reached second easily, he then rounded second and tried to go to third. Drew's attempt for third would end up being a terrible decision as the Tigers completed a tremendous relay that had Drew out by 10 feet. The A’s had cut the lead in half, but Drew’s base running error had stifled their rally.

Most importantly, Stephen Drew’s big hit forced Jim Leyland to take Scherzer out of the game and put in the veteran reliever and former A, Octavio Dotel. Dotel would get Cespedes to strikeout and then he’d walk Brandon Moss. Leyland would then go to the lefty, Phil Coke to face Josh Reddick. Coke would force a fly out that would end the inning, but the inning had reinvigorated the crowd and provided them plenty of hope that the A’s could and would comeback to win.

Blevins would take care of the Tigers in the top of the 7th, forcing three ground ball outs on 6 pitches. Al Albuquerque would do the same in the bottom half, but would throw a few more pitches. The A’s were were still one run down, and now only 6 outs away from seeing their season end.

Matters would only get worse for the A’s in top of the 8th, Sean Doolittle would come into the game. Doolittle would give up a leadoff single to Omar Infante, and then once again, the Tigers would play small ball by making Austin Jackson bunt allowing Infante to go to second with one out. Avisail Garcia would then pinch hit and he’d come through with a single to right, Infante rounded third and was gonna try and score. Reddick came up throwing but unlike many times during the regular season, Reddick was unable to gun down Infante and now it was 3-1 Tigers. A run like that would usually be devastating  but not for the 2012 A’s, it seemed that almost no deficit was too much for them. Luckily the damage would stop there and with the top of the order coming up in the bottom half, the A’s were running out of opportunities. 

The bottom of the 8th seemed to be the A’s best chance to comeback and tie the game. After Cliff Pennington, Coco Crisp and the rest of the A’s top of the order would be coming up. Joaquin Benoit would come in for the Tigers as their usual setup man. The inning would start off with groundout from Pennington and all of a sudden the Tigers were 5 outs away from the ALCS. Then Coco Crisp came up and could do no more than fly out. Two outs now in the bottom of the 8th, and Stephen Drew was up next. Drew would continue his good night by getting a two strike single to keep the inning alive. Then Yoenis Cespedes would draw a walk as all five pitches he faced were well out of the strike zone.  The Tigers were clearly taking no chances with the A’s best hitter in 2012. It was now first and second with two outs, and Brandon Moss was coming to the plate. Moss had struggled all series but it seemed he was due for a hit in a situation like this. Moss wouldn’t come though, being too aggressive, he’d swing at pitches outside the strike zone and strikeout to end the inning.

It was the top of the 9th and the A’s couldn’t afford to give up any more runs. Bob Melvin sent out Ryan Cook to hold serve while keeping Grant Balfour waiting in the bullpen. Cook would get an easy one-two-three inning and after striking out Alex Avila to end the inning, Cook started yelling and screaming as if to try to get his teammates fired up.

Image credit: Press Democrat 

As if they needed it, the Tigers closer, Jose Valverde was coming into the game. Valverde had been known for his “overzealous” celebrations, whatever that means. In 2011, Valverde had been perfect, 50 save opportunities, 50 saves. In 2012, he finally showed vulnerability by blowing 5 saves. No matter who was on the mound, the A’s had a daunting test right in front of them.

Leading off would be Josh Reddick, besides his home run in game 2, Reddick had been struggling at the plate. There was no better time to break the slump than right now, and Reddick was behind in the count at 1-2. The Tigers continued to throw to Reddick away and get him to roll over. And they did the same for the 1-2 pitch, it was a fastball on the outside corner, low and away and Reddick pulled it into the 3.5 hole (between first and second basemen) and Infante couldn’t get to it. It was a single for Reddick, and all of a sudden the A’s had the building blocks for a comeback in place. 

Next up was Josh Donaldson, and we all remember Donaldson as this tremendous player but at that time, Donaldson was just beginning to showcase his talent. So what he did in this at bat was a lot more surprising then, than it would be now. Donaldson wasted no time, Valverde threw him a fastball out over the plate and Donaldson smacked it into the night sky, it was a question of whether it would stay in the ballpark and it smashed off the jagged edge in left-center and Austin Jackson fired it back into the infield, but not before Donaldson and Reddick would run all the way to second and third, with nobody out.

'

Image credit: Press Democrat

It was now a whole new ballgame, and the crowd was in a frenzy. The A's had done this so many times before but there was still work to be done. Next up came Seth Smith, and the first pitch that Valverde threw to him was three feet wide from the plate, clearly Valverde was feeling every bit of the moment. Then Smith would swing through a pitch out of the strike zone and now it was 1-1. The next pitch from Valverde was out over the plate, and this was one that Smith got the barrel on, right away it was clear it was going into the gap. It got down, Reddick scored with his arms waving around urging Donaldson to score behind him, and he did easily.

Image credit: Press Democrat

It was a tie game, and during all that, Seth Smith ended up at second yelling as the camera came over him. It was a tie ballgame! Now the winning run was on second with nobody out. 

Who’d be the hero that would put his name into the front page headlines? Bob Melvin would send up George Kottaras to pinch hit for Norris, and Kottaras would swing at the first pitch and would pop out to Miguel Cabrera in foul territory. Now it was one out in the inning, Kottaras had given Valverde a gift out, and now thoughts of letting the Tigers off the hook started to creep in.

Those thoughts would get louder in the next at bat, Cliff Pennington would go down looking at a Valverde splitter to get the second out of the inning. Those thoughts would be short-lived though, as up next was Coco Crisp. The man who seemed to be one of the key leaders in the clubhouse for his clutch hits and lively manner was up with the winning run on second. 

With the whole crowd standing, the first pitch came… and it was drilled by Crisp right between Fielder and Infante. It was scorched into RF and Avisail Garcia charged it to try and get a running start and throw out Smith, but it went under his glove.... and when that happened, the game was over.

Image credit: Press Democrat 

Image credit: SFgate 

The A’s had kept their season alive in one of the most dramatic ways ever imagined! A two run deficit in the 9th, and a walk-off. ANOTHER ONE!! This was the 15th walk-off of the year, and it was probably the biggest of them all. 

See the entire game right HERE. And see the A's comeback right HERE. During Crisp’s walk-off, A’s radio play-by-play man, Ken Korach was going crazy but not nearly as crazy as his color commentator, Ray Fosse who screamed as the ball went under Garcia’s glove. This moment became known as the #FosseScream and is one of the most memorable moments in A’s folklore during the 2012 season.

The series was now tied at 2-2, and the deciding game 5 was coming the next night. And many of you are probably asking? Why is this win only at #10? And it’s real simple, this was a wonderful win, but it did not inspire a huge run for the A’s. If the A’s had won game 5 and had gone onto win the World Series that year, this win is probably in the top 5 but because Justin Verlander shut the A’s out the very next night, it lost a some of its value on our ranking.

Still, this was a great moment, and that can’t be argued with. If you disagree with me about the importance of this game, please explain why in the comments, or please feel free to share with us your memory of this great game!

Stay tuned, #9 is coming up next!

-- Wes

Get your Champion Gear at www.Section148.com

#11 The Unlikely Hero

There are certain A's games that when they get brought up nearly every A’s fan will remember and talk about them at great length. For some reason, the game featured as Win #11 in our 25 Greatest A's Win's weekly countdown is not one of those games, but as you’ll find out in this post, it’s one that should be talked about more often! 

So many great story lines came out of this game and on this day, your Oakland A’s got one step closer to winning their second straight pennant.

After a few posts in the 21st Century, we now return to October 9, 1973, for game 3 of the 1973 American League Championship Series. Dick Williams and the 1973 A’s were used to hard fought playoff series, in fact, up to that point, every playoff series they had been in had gone the distance. Once again, Earl Weaver’s Baltimore Orioles proved that this series was going to go down to the wire.  The teams seemed evenly matched, loaded with great pitching to go along with timely hitting. Weaver’s Orioles had won 3 American League pennants in a row between 1969-1971, and one of those came at the expense of the A’s in 1971. The Orioles would win the title in 1970 and they’d nearly repeat in 1971 before losing in 7 games.

Up to this point, the series had left Baltimore Memorial Stadium split 1-1. The Orioles took game 1 behind their ace Jim Palmer who pitched a complete game shutout while Vida Blue was knocked out in the first inning.  Game 1 ended 6-0 Orioles. Game 2 was where the A’s showed true to their moniker as the “Swingin’ A’s” where they belted the Orioles starter, Dave McNally, hitting 4 home runs in a 6-3 win for Oakland. Two of those game 2 home runs came off the bat of the captain, Sal Bando and A’s leadoff man, Bert Campaneris, who hit the “Rickey Henderson” shot.   For those of you who don’t know, the "Rickey Henderson" is a home run to leadoff the game (Rickey hit more leadoff home runs than anyone all-time). 

After two split games in Baltimore, the series would head to Oakland for the final three games (2-3 being the championship series format at that time). Game 3 would be a tremendous matchup between two veterans in Mike Cuellar of the Orioles and Ken Holtzman of the A’s. For the 34,367 in attendance at the Coliseum, this game was one that none of them will forget.

There was no offensive prowess in the first inning, which would be a foreshadowing for much of the game, but there is one thing to note. Holtzman would find himself in a jam due to an uncharacteristic Dick Green error but he’d then strikeout the young, Don Baylor to end the inning. Cuellar would face the minimum with no strikeouts.

The second inning would not be too kind to Ken Holtzman. The leadoff hitter, and the future Hall of Famer, Brooks Robinson would groundout to his opposite number, Sal Bando for the first out. The next batter would provide the Orioles' solo spark of offense for the day.  Earl Williams would get a Holtzman fastball up and in, but Holtzman caught too much of the plate, and Williams made him pay by launching it over the left field wall for a solo homer. With Holtzman possibly still frustrated about giving up that home run, Andy Etchebarren would then line out but luckily it didn’t cost him. Holtzman clearly refocused by striking out, Mark Belanger to end the inning. The score after one and a half was 1-0 Orioles.

In the bottom of the second, Reggie Jackson would continue his frustrating slump in the series by striking out, he only had one hit for the series and the A’s were going to have to find a way to step up with the 1973 AL MVP struggling. In the scoreless inning, Deron Johnson would walk to give the A’s their first baserunner but he’d get no further as Cuellar’s slider and screwball were keeping the A’s off balance.

The next several innings would provide almost no offense, and not only that, the innings were going by quick since strikeouts were coupled with quick at bats. Batters clearly didn’t have a clue on how to beat these pitchers. Holtzman would say after the game that he didn’t have his best stuff, his curveball really wasn’t working so he only threw it a few times while going with the fastball the majority of his outing. Cuellar on the other hand, was doing it with nasty breaking pitches like his slider and his screwball that forced A’s hitters to guess pitches.

After Holtzman gave up the homer to Earl Williams, he’d retire the next 11 batters before giving up a walk to Tommy Davis in the top of the 7th, and that walk would get cancelled out by a 1-4-3 (there’s a popular pager message. Right, Ray J?) double play hit by Don Baylor. Brooks Robinson would then reach on a Dick Green error which was his second error of the day, but Holtzman would show great poise by getting Earl Williams to hit into a force at second to end the inning with no damage done.

The bottom of the 7th was more of the same from Cuellar. He’d get strikeouts of Tenace and Johnson in a one-two-three inning. With Cuellar definitely going the distance, the A’s needed to find the solution rather quickly - needing a run with only 6 outs left. Holtzman would get a one-two-three inning in the top of the 8th against the Orioles bottom of the order.

In the bottom of the 8th, Dick Williams knew he had to take no chances with his personnel decisions. He looked to his bench where Jesus Alou was chomping at the bit for an opportunity. Williams called Alou's number to pinch hit for Ray Fosse. Jesus Alou would get a bit of luck to go the A’s way as his hit to left field fell down for a bloop single. Suddenly, the A’s had a possible lifeline.  Dick Williams wasted no time in pinch running for Alou with the speedy, Allan Lewis. He’d then pinch hit Dick Green with Mike Andrews and immediately ordered him to lay down a sacrifice bunt. Andrews laid one down and it wasn’t the greatest bunt in the world, Cuellar had a play at second and Orioles catcher, Andy Etchebarren yelled at Cuellar to throw to second but apparently Cuellar couldn’t hear him due to the crowd noise and he threw to first to get the out there. This is all came from Etchebarren’s quote about the play after the game. It wasn’t even a capacity crowd, and Etchebarren would go onto say that the crowd is where the real advantage is as the playing surfaces play similar.

The A’s might’ve been fortunate in that situation, but the execution by the A’s was still impressive. Campaneris would strikeout in the next at bat, making it two outs in the inning. Just when A’s fans might have thought that their opportunity had been dashed, Joe Rudi was there to save the day. Cuellar would jam Rudi inside and he even broke Rudi’s bat but the ball dropped down in the outfield and Lewis raced around third to tie the game at 1-1!

In the top of the 9th, Gene Tenace would move from first to catcher and Vic Davilillo would come in to play first. Ted Kubiak would replace Mike Andrews at second to complete Oakland's defensive changes. A complete game was on the line for Hotlzman as he prepared to face the Orioles middle of the order. Holtzman would get the scrappy Grich to fly out but then Paul Blair would slap a single to center and all of a sudden there was some concern. The concern only grew worse when Tommy Davis would hit a grounder to Davalillo at first.  Davalillo would step on first and then throw to second to try and get the the double play, but the throw was wide and landed in the outfield. Blair raced to third as a result. An error was given to Davalillo, and now there were two outs in the inning with a runner on third for Don Baylor. Don Baylor had already failed twice with runners on the base, and he had a chance to redeem himself in this at bat. Meanwhile, Dick Williams had Rollie Fingers warming up in the bullpen. Managers like Leo Durocher would have probably gone with Fingers in this at bat, but that was never Williams’ style, he liked to give his starters a long leash and allow them to pitch out of trouble.

Williams’ loyalty to Holtzman was rewarded as Baylor struck out, failing once again in a critical situation. It was a huge moment in the game and Holtzman showed real determination in getting Baylor for the third out.

Until the bottom of the 11th inning, both pitchers would stay in the game with neither pitcher showing any signs of fatigue, something unheard of in today’s MLB. From the bottom of the 9th to the bottom of the 11th, neither team would see a baserunner with both pitchers giving pitching performances for the ages.

Then came the bottom of the 11th, leading off the inning would be Bert Campaneris. The A’s leadoff hitter had struggled the last month of the season and had only hit 4 homers during the year which was a low that he hadn’t experienced since 1969. He had hit one in Baltimore during game 2 but by no means was anyone expecting Campaneris to flash power as he was more regarded for being a speedy, contact hitter.

In the at bat, Campaneris was looking for a slider inside. He wanted to see if he could hit it down the line with Robinson playing off the line. Campaneris got the pitch from Cuellar that he was looking for and when he hit it, he knew it was going a long way. Campaneris watched the ball with both eyes and he started to think it might be caught by the way the left fielder, Don Baylor was playing it. Baylor then stood at the wall, jumped up and when he came down, he didn’t have the ball. The ball had gone over the wall for a walk-off home run! Not just any walk-off, this was the first postseason walk-off home run in Oakland A’s history! 

Campaneris raised both fists in the air in celebration, Dick Williams gave Holtzman a huge hug in appreciation of his wonderful performance in this game. 

And all of a sudden, the A’s were one win away from the World Series!

This walk-off home run was ranked by David Schoenfield of ESPN.com as the 21st greatest postseason walk-off in history (though the list was made back in 2011). On the Baltimore side, WNST.com’s Dwayne Showalter ranked this home run as one of the most devastating home runs given up by the Orioles in Showalter’s lifetime. Yup, it’s right up there with Raul Ibanez’s heroics in the 2012 ALDS.

And in a game where two pitchers went more than just the distance, but went into the 11th inning and considering the fact that it was a pivotal playoff game, this game climbed up our list. Campy surprised everyone (including the local media) by providing the blast and becoming the hero of the game. Amazingly, Campy had only hit four homers during the entire regular season, and yet with this home run, he has already reached half that total for the postseason.

We were not able to find any videos or color photographs from this game. The pictures in this post came from the archive known as newspapers.com.

We’ll be doing more on the 1973 A’s later on in this countdown, so stay tuned. And also, if you are just stumbling across this weekly series, now’s a great time to start - the top 10 wins is filled with epic moments that all A’s fans will likely remember well! We're all over it! 

Stay tuned, we’re starting the top 10 next week!

-- Wes

Get your Champion Gear at www.Section148.com

Video Challenge: Why Are You an A's Fan?

We want to know, why are you an A's fan? 

We'll watch all the videos and pick 5 winners at random to receive special discount codes.  We will also pick 1 winner to receive 2 free tickets to attend the Oakland A's FanFest 2015, and a free shirt of their choice!  

So get cracking with those fancy cell phone video cameras, because all entries must be received by Monday, January 26, 2015 at 11:59 p.m. PST.  

We will announce the winners shortly thereafter and arrange for delivery of the discount codes, Fan Fest tickets and free shirt. 

GOOD LUCK! 

-- Jamie

Get your Champion Gear at www.Section148.com

#12 The New Beginning

We continue our 25 Greatest Oakland A's Wins weekly countdown, by returning to October 1, 2000 for a beautiful day in Oakland.  Win #12 was between the Texas Rangers and Oakland A’s, on the same day that key pieces of the A’s teams of the late 80s (Walt Weiss and Luis Polonia) played their last games of their respective careers. The stakes were as big as they come, with an A’s win they would clinch their first division championship since 1992, a loss with a Mariners win would send the A’s likely into a tiebreaker game against the Cleveland Indians for the Wildcard.

After the 1999 season, optimism was really on the rise when it came to the A’s. Tremendous young pitching that were all the products of homegrown talent were about to all finally make it to the major leagues. The trio that would be affectionately known as the “The Big 3” featured Mark Mulder who was drafted 2nd overall in the 1998 Draft out of Michigan State, Tim Hudson who was more of a wildcard and was drafted in the 6th round in 1997, and lastly, Barry Zito who was drafted 9th overall in the 1999 Draft when everyone thought the A’s were crazy for falling in love with him.It’s incredible that the A’s were able to hit on all those big draft picks. Mark Mulder was the sure thing, while Zito and Hudson were the ones that caught the whole league with their pants down. 

While on the position player side, Eric Chavez was drafted 10th overall in the 1996 Draft and after being considered a weak defensive third baseman he later became arguably the best defensive third baseman in franchise history. Then there was Jason Giambi, a second round pick in 1992 and as a 29 year old had flashed his true potential with 43 homers to go along with leading the league in walks in 2000 which was enough to beat Frank Thomas for the AL MVP that season. Then there was the great international amateur signing that was Miguel Tejada in 1993 (even though he lied about his age but I forgive him) and the drafting of 1998 rookie of the year, Ben Grieve.

The only notable mistake the A’s made in amateur scouting seemed to be in the 1995 Draft where director of scouting, Grady Fuson (aka the guy who Billy fired in the movie Moneyball, even though that never happened) reportedly had two choices: a Cuban pitcher named Ariel Prieto and a power hitting first baseman out of the University of Tennessee named Todd Helton. The A’s took Prieto and Helton went to the Rockies three picks later. Helton would go onto make 5 All-Star appearances and win three gold gloves, while Prieto would be better known as being Yoenis Cespedes’ translator. You can’t win them all, but imagine the A’s having Todd Helton to go along with all the other talent previously mentioned.

Now to the game, going into the Texas series the A’s were a half game out of first. They knew they were likely going to have to sweep the Rangers, and hope that the Mariners drop at least one game in their final series against the Angels. Likely for the A’s, the Mariners would drop the Friday night contest against the Angels and coupled with an A’s win on Friday in a comeback win against Kenny Rogers, the A’s were back in first place with two to play. The A’s would crush the Rangers in the Saturday game by a score of 23-2 with Barry Zito cementing his status as a phenom. The Mariners would also win their game by killing the Angels 21-9 so the A’s were still up half a game. The stakes were simple, a win, and you’re in. And the 19 game winner Tim Hudson was just the man the A’s wanted in this pivotal last game of the season.

For the Rangers, they had nothing to play for and they threw out the young Ryan Glynn to start the game. And from the beginning, it was clear that the blowout in the game the night before was going to have no carryover effects for this game. Hudson would strikeout the first two batters he faced, he’d surrender a Rafael Palmeiro double off the wall but would negate it by getting Chad Curtis to groundout to Miguel Tejada at shortstop.

Ryan Glynn would get the same result but he’d do it in a different fashion. He’d get the leadoff hitter, Terrence Long to groundout and then he’d give up a single to the veteran, Randy Velarde. Jason Giambi was up next and Glynn would give the Giambino nothing to hit and walked him on 5 pitches. Then came the Canadian, Matt Stairs who would ground into a 3-6-1 double play to end the inning.

From that inning to the 7th inning, the pitchers duel was in full effect as both teams combined for miserly three hits. The plan seemed pretty clear for Glynn when it came to dealing with the A’s best hitter, Jason Giambi. They were only going to pitch to him when they absolutely had to do so, in his first three appearances, Giambi was walked each time and he faced an average of 6 pitches in those at bats.

Hudson was absolutely dominating the Rangers lineup, forcing strikeouts and weak contact and it was clear that any runs were going to the difference. And Hudson faced trouble in the top of the 5th, facing the bottom of the Rangers order, Hudson gave up a leadoff single to Mike Lamb and then he’d hit Scott Sheldon with an 0-1 pitch to make the situation first and second with nobody out. With the 9 hitter, Randy Knorr coming up, Rangers manager, Johnny Oates would give his catcher the bunt sign and Knorr would execute it by getting it deep to the right side of the infield where Tim Hudson would only be able tag Knorr out for the first out of the inning. The leadoff hitter, Scarborough Green would be up next and in a game changing situation. It is unclear as to what depth A’s manager, Art Howe used in this situation. We can only speculate thanks to the lack of recaps available on the internet.

Hudson knew he had to go for the strikeout, anything hit out of the infield would likely bring at least one run home. He’d get Green into an 0-2 situation, and with Green having to protect, he swung at the next pitch and it was a ground ball. I’m just going to guess that the A’s were playing the infield in and Green had to of hit it right at Velarde if that was the case. Velarde received ball and fired a strike to Ramon Hernandez the catcher and the would be, go ahead run was gunned down and now there were two outs in the inning.

With runners at the corners and two outs for Royce Clayton, who ironically would play Miguel Tejada in the movie Moneyball was coming to the plate. Green would steal second base easily to take away the force, but it wouldn’t matter as Hudson would get Clayton to ground to the man he’d portray in a movie 10 years later, Miguel Tejada, to end the inning with no damage done.

Then came the bottom of the 7th, Glynn continued to stifle the A’s lineup and the first two batters of the bottom of the 7th were no different. He’d get Grieve to fly out and then would get Eric Chavez to strikeout, seemingly ending another chance to put the A’s in pole position. That thought changed when Jason’s little brother, Jeremy Giambi doubled down the right field line giving the inning a much needed shot in the arm. The catcher, Ramon Hernandez was up and he was extra aggressive, swinging at the first pitch and lined a base hit into centerfield, Jeremy rounded third, the throw came home from Green but it was not in time and the A’s had found the run they needed, 1-0 and 6 outs away from the division title.

The 8th inning started with some more magic from Tim Hudson who if he hadn’t already, had cemented his status as the ace of the A’s staff. Former Oakland A, Ruben Sierra would pinch hit for the Rangers and would go down swinging to Hudson for the first out. Then Hudson would get Scarborough Green to strikeout for the second out. A Royce Clayton double would bring some nerves to A’s fans especially with the dangerous Rafael Palmeiro coming up, the A’s would intentionally walk him and take their chances with Chad Curtis. And he’d groundout to Tejada who’d flip the ball to Velarde to end the inning. Now there were 3 outs away.

The A’s fans would then breathe a lot easier with how the bottom of the 8th started, Ryan Glynn would spell the end to his outing by giving up a long towering home run by Randy Velarde on a 2-1, money pitch. It was now 2-0 and the Coliseum crowd was sensing a dog pile was coming. The Rangers would bring in Mike Venafro to pitch to Jason Giambi, and he’d get Giambi to fly out to center. The Rangers would then bring in Tim Crabtree to face Matt Stairs, and as a result, A’s manager Art Howe brought in Olmedo Saenz to pinch hit. And Olmedo Saenz would jump on Crabtree’s first pitch and now the score was 3-0. Two solo home runs had begun the party in Oakland, a clutch move by Art Howe to say the least.

Then came the 9th inning, Hudson had thrown 120 pitches in a valiant, bulldog effort that was a masterful pitching performance. His outing was over and his line read: 8.0 IP, 4 H, 0 ER, 2 BB, 10 SO, and a game score of 82. Art Howe knew it was time to bring in his closer, Jason Isringhausen who’d be going for his 33rd save of the year. Seattle was winning their game so it was all on the A’s to just get these 3 outs to end the discussion. Isringhausen would get Ricky Ledee to hit a loud out to deep right field, one out. Then Pedro Valdes would single, and the next batter, Mike Lamb would do the same. Now it was starting to get interesting as the tying run was coming to the plate, Scott Sheldon trying to be the hero would hit a foul popup to Eric Chavez and now the A’s were one out away. The Rangers would send Frank Catalanotto to pinch hit, and one of the most iconic A’s plays would occur in this moment. Isringhausen would bring the count to 1-2 and the Coliseum’s crowd was on its feet and then Isringhausen got into the stretch and it was clear it was the big curveball, Catalanotto froze and the umpire made the move, the ballgame was over. Greg Papa, the A’s TV play-by-play man at the time would give this call, “CURVEBALL, IT’S OVER!!!!!!! FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE '92, THE OAKLAND A’S ARE CHAMPIONS OF THE AMERICAN LEAGUE WEST!” Ramon Hernandez mauled Isringhausen in the middle of the diamond, then came the infield, then came the men from the dugout, and followed by the bullpen and the outfield, the drought was over.

An incredible regular season ended the way it should’ve, and the young team had finally grown up and done what everyone had envisioned. It was now time for the playoffs, a grueling back and forth series with the two-time defending champion, New York Yankees ensued. The A’s would beat Roger Clemens twice in that series, but it wasn’t enough, Gil Heredia became the goat in the minds of all A’s fans as he gave up 6 runs in the first inning of the deciding game 5 and they’d end up losing 7-5 in front of their home fans. The Yankees would go onto win another World Series but the A’s new window had just begun and at the time, it was a time of excitement for all A’s fans.

We could not find any more photos or any videos from this game, if you have any, please tweet them at us or post them in our Facebook comments.

Just one update, last week’s post “The Sulk Off” has now added videos so please check that out by scrolling down the page to that post.

Next up is #11, stay tuned!

-- Wes

Get your Champion Gear at www.Section148.com

#13 The Sulk Off

After last week’s breakdown of Jerry Blevins’s Great Escape, we stay in the 21st Century and continue our 25 Greatest A's Wins countdown with another classic A's v. Angels game, from August 11, 2005. Win #13 was one of the most bizarre finishes I’ve ever seen,but it’s a victory that was truly fitting and encapsulated the rivalry between the A’s and Angels at that point in time.

Some of you may be thinking, “but the A’s don’t have any real rivalries?” And that may be a valid discussion worthy of an entire (and separate) post! Most A's fans have varying levels of disdain for the San Francisco Giants, but we only play them 6 times a year at the most.  It’s very difficult for the players to join in the rivalry, so it’s merely more of a fan rivalry. Not to mention, the Giants rival is the Dodgers. The Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim, on the other hand, are our true rival.  Or, at least, have been for the last decade.  

For a little bit of background, the A’s had developed a solid core group of players in the early 2000s and won the AL West title in 2000, 2002, 2003, and 2006. In the 2002 season, the Angels had won the Wild Card in the same year that the A’s won 20 games in a row.  Unfortunately, the A's bowed out to the Twins in the ALDS.  The Angels, however, would go on from the Wild Card to win the AL Pennant and then beat the Giants in the World Series to win their first World Series title. 

Ironically, the Angels made their big postseason statement to the A's and the entire MLB in the same year that they did some rebranding and had changed their colors from a baby blue color to a solid red color.  What’s even more ironic is that the same year the Anaheim Ducks did similar rebranding is the same year they won their only Stanley Cup.

The Angels had players who were very easy for A’s fans to hate. Two players immediately come to mind: their closer, Francisco Rodriguez (aka K-Rod), and their longtime starting pitcher, John Lackey. They also had an annoying manager who still manages them to this day, Mike Scioscia. And with both teams being good, year in and year out, the rivalry was born. 

In 2004, the rivalry really reached heated proportions, as the A’s led the AL West all the way up until the last series of the season where Mark Mulder (in his last game as an Oakland A) and the once solid reliever, Ricardo Rincon choked the division away. The Angels celebrated the division title in Oakland.

The Angels were owned by Disney up until 2005, when they were bought by Arte Moreno who went onto change the name of the Angels from the “Anaheim Angels” to the “Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim” despite the small fact that the team was not actually located in LA County. It was already easy to make fun of the Angels for being owned by Disney and the gimmicks, including the Rally Monkey and thundersticks. 

With the name change, A's fans were only given more ammunition to fire against the Angels.

The 2005 season was supposed to be an A’s team in transition after trading away Tim Hudson and Mark Mulder, two members of the A’s “Big 3”, who were hitting their arbitration years. The 2005 A’s starting pitching rotation’s average age would be 25-years-old with rookies like Joe Blanton and Dan Haren (who was brought over in the Mulder trade). In the bullpen, a young 21-year-old closer from the University of Texas named Huston Street showed impressive growth during the 2005 season. He’d go onto win the rookie of the year later that season.

The 2005 position players were lacking in star power, but plenty of homegrown  talent made the A’s a solid team: guys like Nick Swisher, Dan Johnson, and Eric Chavez, along with veterans like Mark Kotsay, Jay Payton, and Jason Kendall.

When the sun rose on August 11, in the 2005 season, the A’s were tied with the Angels for first place. The A’s had already had quite a season. They went 12-12 in April, and had a rough month of May going 7-20, but then they became the hottest team in baseball going 19-8 in June, and 20-6 in July.

The game on August 11 would be the finale of a pivotal 3 game set that saw the A’s and Angels split the first two games. This game would be a radio only game with a 12:35 first pitch at the Coliseum. Sadly, this was one of the last games Bill King would do the play-by-play as after the season the legendary A’s radio broadcaster would pass away. The rookie, Joe Blanton would be on the mound for the A’s on August 11. For the Angels, it would be Paul Byrd. Both happened to be soft tossing righties who didn't rack up a lot of strikeouts.

It began with a quiet 1st inning.  The top of the 2nd inning began with a home run from the Angels’ Dominican slugger, Vladimir Guerrero who feasted on pitchers like Joe Blanton and proved his point by belting a 2-0 pitch to left-center to give the Angels a 1-0 lead. Both pitchers would flirt with danger for the next couple of innings.  

Byrd gave up 2 hits to the A’s in the bottom of the 2nd, 3rd, and 5th innings, but didn't give up any runs in that time frame. For his turn, Blanton gave up 2 hits in the top of the 3rd and 4th innings, but unlike Byrd, Blanton would pay for it in the 4th, as doubles from Maicer Izturis and Adam Kennedy, the scrappy players on the Angels, plated a run and made it 2-0 Angels. Action didn't pick up until the 7th inning.

The top of the 7th inning would see the end of Joe Blanton’s day as he hit the century mark of 100 pitches to end the top of the 6th.  The long reliever, the late Joe Kennedy, who had recently been picked up in a trade with the Rockies, came in for relief. Kennedy had struggled with the A’s and would continue on this day. The speedy Chone Figgins hit a leadoff double, but ironically some bad base running saw Figgins tagged out in a pickle in the next at bat.  During the pickle, Orlando Cabrera advanced to second with one out. Darin Erstad would then groundout to make it two outs, but Cabrera would advance to third. The next batter was Vladimir Guerrero and the A’s wisely decided to intentionally walk him. Scioscia would send up Bengie Molina to pinch hit. Scioscia, being extra aggressive, would give Guerrero the steal sign and now the situation was second and third with no one out. And once again, Kennedy had to intentionally walk Molina. It was now bases loaded with two outs for Steve Finley.

Steve Finley then lined one over the head of Swisher, and it was clear right away that it was going to score two, as Cabrera walked home and Guerrero jogged in standing up. The slow running Molina would get to third and stop on Finley’s double. It was now 4-0 Angels. They were only 9 outs away from the victory that would allow them to retake first place. No further damage was done, but now the A’s winning probability was down to 6%.

Byrd’s day was done after he forced two double plays that allowed him to pitch 6 shutout innings. Scioscia went to his bullpen for the Angels usual 7th inning man, Brendan Donnelly who was memorable for his coke bottle glasses. It was clear right away that it was a tough day to be a reliever! Donnelly right away gave up a home run to the recently acquired, Jay Payton who didn’t waste any time, swinging at the first pitch.  Payton crushed a no doubter, solo home run to make the deficit 4-1 Angels.

Back to back singles by Mark Ellis and Jason Kendall really got the A’s going. Kotsay would hit a ground ball to the right side of the infield, and Darin Erstad was only able to step on first to get one out, allowing Kendall and Ellis to advance to second and third. Bobby Crosby would then strikeout on three pitches, in a critical at bat, and the A’s hitting woes appeared to be continuing. Next up was Eric Chavez. The star third baseman gave the A’s just what they needed as he lined a pitch over the wall for a three run home run to tie the game! That quickly, it was 4-4.  

The 8th inning would see clean innings from relievers on both sides of the ball.  Justin Duchscherer would throw a clean top half for the A’s and the Angels set up man, Scot Shields would do the same for the Angels in the bottom half.

A’s manager, Ken Macha would make no changes for the top of the 9th, showing plenty of faith in Duchscherer. He’d get the first two batters out with not much hassle then came Vladimir Guerrero who was once again intentionally walked. Once again, Guerrero would steal second base for the second time in this game, which just highlights the problem that Jason Kendall had behind the plate that season with base stealers. Despite the walk and steal, Duchscherer would finish his two innings of work by making Molina hit a pop fly to Mark Ellis to send the game to the bottom of the 9th with the score still at 4-4.

Like Macha, Scioscia would leave Scot Shields in to start the 9th but was ready to bring in his closer, Francisco Rodriguez if need be. The inning would start with a leadoff single from the man known more for his defense, Mark Ellis. Then Macha would signal third base coach, Ron Washington to give Jason Kendall the bunt sign and Kendall laid a bunt down but the bunt was not a good one as Shields was able to throw Ellis out at second and get the force out. Kendall would make it to first but he knew he didn’t get the job done. The inning would be revived with a Mark Kotsay single that made it first and second with one out. And that play would prompt Mike Scioscia to take out Shields and bring in his closer to try and save this critical game.

This man.

As an A's fan, it was easy to hate K-Rod. And on this day, A’s fans were all licking their chops at the possibility of walking off on the Angels star closer and they were 180 feet away from doing so. Bobby Crosby was due up with one out. A single to anywhere but right would likely end the game. Crosby would get a 2-0 count and on the third pitch he grounded to shortstop and A’s fans were thinking that it was going to be an inning ending double play! Luckily it wasn’t, as Crosby beat out the relay to first and now the situation was runners at the corners with two outs for Eric Chavez. On the first pitch of that bat, Bobby Crosby raced from first to second to take away the force play, and it was ruled defensive indifference. 

But what happened on the throw back from Angels catcher, Jose Molina was one that to this day, is quite shocking. K-Rod was clearly upset with the home plate umpire over the first pitch of the at bat ,which was ruled a ball and he let his emotions carry over into his concentration as he was unable to catch the throw back from Molina. The ball rolled over the mound and was between second base and the pitchers mound. During this time, Jason Kendall ran home and it took K-Rod a split second to realize what was going on. By the time K-Rod got it, Kendall had already slid home and the ballgame was over! The A’s had won! The A’s had beaten the Angels and taken over first place. And K-Rod was left to sulk in the middle of the diamond wondering what had just happened.

No direct link to highlights is available. However this link here, will direct you to a long page, scroll down to August 11 to see the Sulk-Off, and the homers by Payton and Chavez.

After the game, K-Rod would say, “A five year old could’ve caught it,” in what certainly had to be the most embarrassing play of his career.

Unfortunately, this game would be the peak of the A’s 2005 season as injuries down the stretch would allow the Angels to take the division in the next month and a half. And once again, the Angels would celebrate on the A’s field.

This game, however would not be the last time that Jason Kendall would cause drama in this rivalry. He’d do this to John Lackey the very next season:

What a lucky guy! And in 2006, the A’s would be ones to win the division. The Angels would then go onto win the AL West in 2007, 2008, and 2009. This century, the A’s and Angels have accounted for 12 division titles between the two of them (the only exceptions being the Mariners in 2001, and the Rangers in 2010, and 2011).

The rivalry was less intense due to a period of time where the Angels were good but the A’s were only mediocre (2007-2009). The rivalry was also less intense when the Rangers were busy winning the AL West (2010-2011). That period was followed by a time where the A’s were back on top and the Angels were overrated (2012-2013). But the A’s and Angels rivalry was reignited in 2014, and I’m excited to see what the next chapter will bring.

Stay tuned, next week is #12!

-- Wes

Get your Champion Gear at www.Section148.com